Bin laden s burial at sea in followed islamic practices, white house insists. Is bin ladens burial at sea really in accordance with islamic tradition. Islamic burial rites with all the questions about if and how the body of osama bin laden was handeled after his death, many have wondered how a body of a deceased muslim is handled. As mentioned in other answers, there is no sea burial practice in islam for a muslim that met hisher demise on land. Osama bin ladens death and the islamic way of burial. Secret details of bin laden burial revealed pakistan news al. May 11, 2011 it was historic when the worlds most wanted man, osama bin laden, was laid to rest somewhere in the arabian sea, which some are calling the ultimate green burial. For a good generation now, the former chief of the c. The disposal of the burial of bin ladens remains was done in strict conformance with islamic precepts and practices, said john o. Burial at sea by aircraft is usually done only with cremated remains. Cnn many muslims around the world expressed confusion monday after a senior u. May 02, 2011 osama bin ladens body was buried at sea but how far the procedures met the requirements of muslim burial law is debatable. Seven years after the death of alqaedas founding leader, osama bin laden, the sunni jihadist movement stands divided. Osama bin ladens body was buried at sea but how far the procedures met the requirements of muslim burial law is debatable.
Just as his life had been a flashpoint of contention, osama bin ladens death has incited fresh disputes about whether his burial at sea was. Michael scheuer, chief of the cias bin laden unit from 1996 to 1999, provides something revealing in his recent book osama bin laden. Advice to muslims on the death of osama bin laden there is a very familiar quote exponded by my father. Furthermore after bin ladens elimination he was buried at sea. The book examines the numerous lies, and the serious damage they caused internationally, surrounding the assassination of osama bin laden, as well as us policy in syria and its impact. Since we do not know the truth let us not speculate and judge. It is incumbent, above all, on rulers to enjoin right, or command good, and also to recog nize the signs of god.
We are ensuring it is handled in accordance with islamic practice and tradition, said a senior. On may 1, 2018, we will have the seventh anniversary of the killing of osama bin laden, the mastermind of the 911 attacks on american soil that took almost 3,000 lives. Traditional procedures for islamic burial was followed, the may 2 email. Bin ladens body buried at sea world news the guardian. Sea burial of osama bin laden breaks sharia law, say. May 02, 2011 bin laden s body buried at sea this article is more than 8 years old us officials say osama bin laden s swift burial complies with islamic custom, although burial at sea is uncommon for muslims. Osama bin laden was a member of the wealthy saudi bin laden family and the founder of the jihadist organization alqaeda, most widely recognized for the september 11 attacks on the united states and numerous other masscasualty attacks against civilian and military targets. Navy gives bin laden a shariahcompliant burial at sea.
The bizarre burial of osama bin laden at sea an action necessitated by our governments need to accommodate islamic law requiring that a muslim be buried within 24 hours of death raises. Osama bin ladens death and the islamic way of burial by. Osama bin laden s burial at sea was quickly criticised by muslim scholars who claimed it had breached sharia law and warned that it may provoke calls for revenge attacks against us targets. Muslim clerics said on monday that osama bin ladens burial at sea was a violation of islamic tradition that may further provoke militant calls for. Bin ladens burial at sea in followed islamic practices, white house insists. What do we really know about osama bin ladens death. Other types of burial at sea include the mixing of the ashes with concrete and dropping the concrete block to form an artificial reef such as the atlantis reef. He was not trained as a religious scholar, and indeed, never claimed to be one, according to michael scheuer, who formerly headed the cias bureau tracking bin laden, in his book, osama bin. May 02, 2018 did bin ladens death help the islamic state. Under islamic tradition, burial at sea is considered inappropriate when other.
In 2010 he was voted britains most influential muslim thinker by jordans royal islamic strategic studies center. Nov 21, 2012 the burial at sea of osama bin laden after he was killed by navy seals followed traditional islamic procedures, according to newly released military emails. Islamic scholars criticize bin ladens sea burial the. Buzz ramps up over seals bin laden book this just in cnn. May 03, 2011 muslim clerics said monday that osama bin ladens burial at sea was a violation of islamic tradition that may further provoke militant calls for revenge attacks against american targets. A book published in november 2011, seal target geronimo, by chuck. Burial at sea of bin laden followed islamic procedures. The body of worlds most wanted terrorist, who was killed today by us special forces in pakistan, was handled in islamic tradition and given a. He was a saudi arabian citizen until 1994 stateless thereafter and a. In light of osama bin ladens death, digital dying speaks with leor halevi, an associate professor of history at vanderbilt university whose 2007 book, muhammads grave. A survey of books about osama bin laden and al qaeda the. Senior us officials told news agencies that his body was disposed of in accordance with islamic tradition, which involves.
March 10, 1957 may 2, 2011, also rendered usama bin ladin, was a founder of the panislamic militant organization alqaeda. Feb, 2011 for a good generation now, the former chief of the c. Why was osama bin laden given an islamic burial if al. Osama bin laden may be dead but the objectives he strove to achieve have in a large part become a reality. There are three sides to every story, their side, your side and the truth. Pentagon officials said monday that bin laden s body was be handled in accordance with muslim traditions, which include strict rules on burial taking place within 24 hours after death. Alqaeda leader osama bin laden was buried at sea from the deck of a u. Bin ladens sea burial was sad miscalculation editors note. Bin ladens burial and other religious frauds jewish journal.
Islamic scholars split over sea burial for bin laden the new york. Video of osama bin ladens dead body being dropped into the north. Osama bin laden his remains were never buried at sea, with leaked emails exposing why the remains of the 911 mastermind might have gone missing. The body of slain alqaeda leader osama bin laden was given an islamic burial and buried at sea amid high secrecy, new emails released. Osama bin laden, the longtime figurehead of the al qaeda terrorist network, has been buried at sea after being killed in a u. Oct 18, 2015 what do we really know about osama bin ladens death. The burial at sea of osama bin laden after he was killed by navy seals followed traditional islamic procedures, according to newly released military emails. You must not read much, not surprising judging by your childlike reaction. Scratch my earlier idea about displaying osama bin ladens body in new york so everyone could set eyes on the uberterrorist and to erase any doubts that he is indeed dead. Background and context osama bin laden was reported killed by us navy seal leader, lamont james ii, on may 1, 2011. Here is an annotated list of some of the more useful books on those subjects. May 02, 2011 bin ladens burial at sea in followed islamic practices, white house insists. Us officials say osama bin ladens swift burial complies with islamic custom, although burial at sea is uncommon for muslims.
Apr 02, 2020 the bizarre burial of osama bin laden at sea an action necessitated by our governments need to accommodate islamic law requiring that a muslim be. Osama bin ladens burial at sea was quickly criticised by muslim. Bin laden s sea burial was sad miscalculation editors note. May 02, 2011 sea burial of osama bin laden breaks sharia law, say muslim scholars. May 04, 2011 he was not trained as a religious scholar, and indeed, never claimed to be one, according to michael scheuer, who formerly headed the cias bureau tracking bin laden, in his book, osama bin. The finish describes a new kind of war fightingthe fusion of intelligence from vast and scattered sourcesto track and apprehend, or kill, the enemy. Osama bin ladens body was taken out to sea and dumped in the north arabian sea from the deck of the uss carl vinson officials have confirmed. Us decision to dispose of body in the sea prevents grave site becoming a shrine but clerics warn it may lead to reprisals. Buzz ramps up over seals bin laden book this just in. He was then buried within 24hours in accordance with islamic tradition, after being given a traditional muslim burial ceremony including being cleaned, dressed in a white robe, and given final rites by a muslim individual. Bin ladens body buried at sea this article is more than 8 years old us officials say osama bin ladens swift burial complies with islamic custom, although burial at. Death rites and the making of islamic society explores everything from funerary wailing and. Five years ago today, seal team 6 killed that murderer, osama bin laden.
In pfarrers account, the total time elapsed from jumping on the roof to osama bin laden s death was between 30 and 90 seconds. Muslim clerics said monday that osama bin ladens burial at sea was a violation of islamic tradition that may further provoke militant calls for revenge attacks against american targets. Osama bin laden sea burial video may be released abc news. Abdal hakim murad is a lecturer in islamic studies at the faculty of divinity, cambridge university, england. Us officials say osama bin ladens swift burial complies with islamic. May 02, 2011 alqaeda leader osama bin laden was buried at sea from the deck of a u. Osama bin laden s body was taken out to sea and dumped in the north arabian sea from the deck of the uss carl vinson officials have confirmed. Oct 27, 2019 warning some of the content of this answer is for mature readers. Bin laden s body buried at sea this article is more than 8 years old us officials say osama bin laden s swift burial complies with islamic custom, although burial at sea is uncommon for muslims. The bin laden book proved to be a very different sort of undertaking. Im not a scholar in islam, but based from what ive learned, here are some points that i know. The burial at sea of osama bin laden after he was killed by navy seals followed. Senior us officials told news agencies that his body was disposed of.
His newest book, the killing of osama bin laden, is an exploration of foreign policy under barack obama. May 02, 2011 osama bin laden, the longtime figurehead of the al qaeda terrorist network, has been buried at sea after being killed in a u. May 02, 2011 osama bin laden was buried at sea from the deck of a u. The body of slain alqaeda leader osama bin laden was given an. Many have also wondered if the united states handling of a deceased muslim body was politically correct. There had been by muslim clerics, such as the imams of pakistan, had the gall they complain the bin laden did not revived and proper islamic burial because he was buried in the ocean and all muslim according to islamic tradition. Feb 02, 2016 his newest book, the killing of osama bin laden, is an exploration of foreign policy under barack obama. The basis for osama bin ladens islamic opposition to. The deputy leader of egypts muslim brotherhood said that, with bin laden. In light of osama bin laden s death, digital dying speaks with leor halevi, an associate professor of history at vanderbilt university whose 2007 book, muhammads grave. Navy seal who says he killed bin laden has book deal. Below is a list of religions that allow burial at sea, with some details of the burial. Why was osama bin laden given an islamic burial if alqaeda. Muslim clerics say osama bin ladens burial at sea is a violation of islamic tradition that may further provoke militant calls for revenge.
Osama bin laden by michael scheuer, paperback barnes. Apr 24, 2018 on may 1, 2018, we will have the seventh anniversary of the killing of osama bin laden, the mastermind of the 911 attacks on american soil that took almost 3,000 lives. The raid on bin ladens compound in abbottabad, pakistan was launched from afghanistan. Among the theses presented and defended by michael scheuer in his 2011 biography osama bin laden, three stand out.
Osama bin laden was buried at sea from the deck of a u. Posted in rexplainlikeimfive by urefinedbear351 122 points and 157 comments. Video of osama bin ladens dead body being dropped into the north arabian sea from the uss carl vinson early this morning will be made. Death rites and the making of islamic society explores everything from funerary wailing and corpse washing to the torture of the spirit in the grave. The bizarre burial of osama bin laden at sea an action necessitated by our governments need to accommodate islamic law requiring that a muslim be. The navy seal who has said he fired the shots that killed osama bin laden has a memoir coming out this spring. Sea burial of osama bin laden breaks sharia law, say muslim scholars. The us navy which doesnt do war of ideas stuff even on a good day. Bin ladens burial at sea in followed islamic practices. It was historic when the worlds most wanted man, osama bin laden, was laid to rest somewhere in the arabian sea, which some are calling the ultimate green burial. Sea burial of osama bin laden breaks sharia law, say muslim. Let allahswt judge forhe is the best and most supreme of all.
Advice to muslims on the death of osama bin ladin islam21c. The first book, and, to date, the definitive one, that looks at the osama bin laden raid from president obamas perspective. Al qaeda war lord osama bin laden was to be blasted in the head by special forces after tracking him to a one million dollar hideaway in abbottabad, pakistan. The burial at sea of osama bin laden after he was killed by navy seals followed traditional islamic procedures, according to newly released. Nov 16, 2019 furthermore after bin ladens elimination he was buried at sea. Posted on may 4, 2011 by askanislamicist im guessing this is something that has been puzzling a lot of people ive gotten a lot of hits recently from people googling some variation of islam and burial, and i got asked it twice at the same time. This book is obviously a piece of propaganda to further convince people that the raid went down the way they say it did. Islamic burial rites the sea burial of osama bin laden. Osama bin laden buried in north arabian sea from deck of. White house officials decided that if american troops killed osama bin laden, they would bury him at sea in order to prevent his grave from. Muslim clerics said on monday that osama bin ladens burial at sea was a violation of islamic tradition that may further provoke militant. We are ensuring that it is handled in accordance with islamic practice and tradition, an administration official said. Since 911, theres been an outpouring of books about osama bin laden, al qaeda, the september 11th attacks and the war in afghanistan. Five years ago today, seal team 6 killed that murderer.
581 1369 944 1600 570 329 1443 121 1376 1312 1317 1257 1361 890 1346 685 1586 370 1198 375 596 389 510 297 239 702 256 585 558 24 738 913 517